What do you do if your feedback in game design is falling on deaf ears?
You've poured hours into analyzing gameplay, mechanics, and user experience, only to find that your feedback seems to be ignored. It's frustrating, but not uncommon in the game design industry. Your insights are valuable, and ensuring they are heard is crucial for the game's success. Remember, you're not just critiquing; you're contributing to a collaborative process where every voice can lead to a more engaging and successful game.
When your feedback isn't acknowledged, it's essential to first clarify your intent. Ensure that your critiques are constructive and aimed at improving the game rather than merely pointing out flaws. By framing your feedback as suggestions for solutions rather than problems, you create a positive dialogue. It's also important to understand the context of the project; perhaps your feedback is relevant, but not a priority at the current stage of development.
If your feedback continues to be overlooked, seek to understand why. Engage in a conversation with the team or individual disregarding your input. Ask questions to uncover any reasons your feedback might not be resonating. It could be a matter of miscommunication or a difference in creative vision. Understanding their perspective can bridge the gap between your feedback and their response.
Effective communication is key in game design. If your feedback isn't getting through, consider adjusting your delivery. Perhaps written feedback isn't as effective as a face-to-face discussion or a visual presentation. Tailoring your communication style to your audience can make a significant difference. Remember, it's not just what you say, but how you say it that can influence how your feedback is received.
Building strong relationships within your team can give your feedback more weight. When you have a rapport with others, they're more likely to listen and consider your input. Invest time in understanding your colleagues' work styles and preferences. A foundation of mutual respect and understanding can ensure that your feedback is taken seriously.
Sometimes, showing is better than telling. If your feedback is being ignored, consider providing clear examples or prototypes that illustrate your point. This can be especially effective if there's resistance to conceptual feedback. Demonstrating a tangible alternative can make your suggestions more compelling and harder to dismiss.
Lastly, don't hesitate to follow up on your feedback. If you've given it some time and there's still no acknowledgment, check in with the team or individual. A gentle reminder that you're awaiting a response or discussion can prompt action. Persistence shows that you're committed to the project's success and believe in the value of your feedback.
-
One of the great ways I found to deal with this is to get your GDD and transform it into a 10-slide PowerPoint with simple graphs, and almost no text. People often don't read the GDD or don't understand the design goals, by making simple images describing stuff in images, with circles with arrows, not only do they understand it better, but you as a designer understand better how to talk about said feature. This is a way to break a big info dump, into simple, easy-to-follow images, simplifying communication and creating documents that could help even in the future.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Game DesignWhat do you do if your boss's feedback in the game design industry feels overwhelming?
-
Game DesignWhat are effective ways to encourage constructive criticism in your game design team?
-
Thought LeadershipHow can feedback develop creativity?
-
Game DevelopmentHow can you deliver consistent feedback across a game development team?