Keeps my water cold all day 14 hour days. The lid is constructed very well it's tough. I noticed that if have the jug filled up a little to far and you screw the lid on with the top cap in place, it will push water out from around the lid. However if you remove the cap and then screw on the lid the water is pushed up instead of out around the lid. Been using it for several weeks now with no complaints.
In the picture Size comparison JBL speaker flip 4, paper towels, 22oz tumbler

I needed a container to hold at least 80 oz of liquid for our hot Arizona summers. Stanley came through with 96 ounces! It is easy to fill and easy to drink from. The handle is tough and feels secure. I have not tested hot liquids, but this container with just cold water, no ice, will remain cold 24 hours later. That is with our summer temps.

This thing is perfect. I work from my SUV 12 hours a day and I have this on my passenger’s seat. It keeps the water from warming up. I have has it on its side and have no leaking issues. The handle is made of metal with plastic (for smooth grip). For me this is perfect because it is nearly a gallon of water. I can’t speak about if it keeps water “ice” cold because I do not like drinking water that cold. But, it has been great at keeping my water cold (around 60 degrees or so). I only put a few ice cubes in to lower the temperature less than room temp.

I had a half gallon jug made by Artic. It didn't hold ice over the weekend. But this one definitely does. I work in a hot environment mu jug is with me 90 + degrees all day it doesn't sweat and my drink is ice cold not just at work but for literally days. I haven't seen how long g it holds ice because I fill it constantly and top it off. But I use less ice now and it stays cold so the ice doesn't melt unless what I add is warm.